I sadly wasn't able to go to the soft opening on Halloween night since I was working at Atlanta Zombie Apocalypse, but you better believe I was there for opening day on November 4th. I drug a few friends from school with me for lunch around 1pm and it was hopping! We put our name on the list and after a surprisingly short wait we were seated and on our way to deliciousness!
After scoping out the menu Martha and I got Black Cherry sodas while Justin braved the Tiger's Blood. (I say braved because we really weren't sure what Tiger's Blood was, but it sounded cool so he ordered it.) For food: I got the Fryinstein Monster and Poutined Fries (Poutined is gravy and cheese curds), Martha got the 100% beef frank and cheese fries (she's boring and only eats 3 things ever so the fact that there was something she wanted was pretty amazing!), and Justin joined me in Fryinstein goodness! (Funnily enough, Justin had already eaten lunch when I text him to go to Pallookaville, but he could not resist the siren call!)
Tiger's Blood turned out to be a fruit punch type flavor (who knew) and the Black Cherry sodas were delicious! The food came out really quickly, which was impressive with how busy they were. Everything was delicious, but I admit I was defeated by the fries and corn dog and had to take half of it to go. I went to school right after and gave the left overs to Xander because he is Canadian and nothing makes him happier than Poutined Fries, seriously you would have thought I gave him a brick of gold he was so happy!
The staff was great, it does help me feel comfortable that I knew quite a few people that work there, however I did not know our waitress and she was super awesome. They asked if we wanted to separate our checks when we went up to pay, that's so rare that somewhere will ask rather than you having to ask them. Seriously, that little extra touch of awesome customer service already sets this amazing place ahead of many others. Not to mention the super amazing atmosphere that is a cross between the old soda shops of the 1950s and the best carnival parts of Coney Island which includes lots of autographed photos up on the wall from many of Jim Stacy's amazing life experiences. From his amazing hidden eatery show Get Delicious, to being a previous partner in the Star Bar and the Starlight Drive-In, Jim has always been ahead of the curve on what's hot just by being true to himself and what he enjoys doing.
So yeah, that was last Monday and I have a lunch date there with my bestie on Wednesday. At about 2 miles from my apartment, I think that Pallookaville will be a regular stop on my culinary rotation. Once I've tried everything on the menu maybe I'll do an update. Did I mention there are seasonal items as well?
UPDATE 11/13/2013: Went to lunch there today and had the Pastrami Reuben, poutined fries (I may have a pouitne problem) and a Butterscotch Soda. My bestie Andy had the B. Franklin with swiss fries and a butterscotch soda and Martha again had her hot dog and cheddar cheese fries with a coke. The Reuben was AMAZING, with the fries I could only eat half of my sandwich since it's a HALF POUND OF MEAT! I traded a bite of my sandwich for a bite of the B. Franklin, it was also wonderfully delicious. Everything is so much food, at well over 6 feet tall I can only assume that everything there is Jim sized! Andy is the only one of us that made it to the clean plate club today.